Skip to main content
bank

First Internet Bank Of Indiana

Fishers, IN · Est. 1998 · Website ↗
B
Trust Grade
Strong
Score: 84/100

First Internet Bank Of Indiana is a bank based in Fishers, Indiana, established in 1998, with $5.7 billion in total assets across 2 branches. By Trust Grade it ranks 83rd of 89 banks we track in Indiana. Its capital ratio of 7.6% trails most similarly sized banks (6th percentile), versus a Indiana median of 9.6%. It was profitable over the most recent period, with a 0.32% return on assets. No consumer complaints against First Internet Bank Of Indiana appear in the CFPB database over our analysis window — common for an institution of this size and a point in its favor.

Total assets
$5.7B
$1B–10B institution
Deposits
$5.0B
Branches
2
Capital ratio
7.6%
Bottom 6% of $1B–10B peers · Indiana median 9.6%
Return on assets
0.3%
Bottom 7% of $1B–10B peers · Indiana median 1.05%
Rank in Indiana
#83
of 89 banks

How First Internet Bank Of Indiana compares to Indiana peers

Capital ratio
Bottom 6% of $1B–10B peers
First Internet
7.6%
Indiana median
9.6%
Higher capital ratio = stronger financial cushion
Return on assets
Bottom 7% of $1B–10B peers
First Internet
0.3%
Indiana median
1.1%
Higher ROA = more profitable relative to asset base

How we graded First Internet Bank Of Indiana

The Trust Grade blends financial strength with complaint history. Full methodology →

Financial strength
84/100
Customer experience
n/a
Overall
B · 84
  • Well-capitalized (7.6% capital ratio)
  • Profitable (ROA 0.32%)
  • No CFPB complaints on record

Consumer complaints (CFPB)

No CFPB complaints are on file for First Internet Bank Of Indiana over the analysis window. For a smaller institution this is common and counts in its favor.

Branch locations (2)

  • 51 W 3rd St, Tempe, AZ 85281
  • 8701 E 116th St, Fishers, IN 46038

Are deposits at First Internet Bank Of Indiana insured?

Yes. First Internet Bank Of Indiana is an FDIC-insured bank (FDIC certificate #34607). Deposits are federally insured up to $250,000per depositor, per ownership category — regardless of this institution's Trust Grade. The grade reflects financial strength and complaint history for comparison, not the safety of insured deposits.

First Internet Bank Of Indiana: frequently asked questions

Is First Internet Bank Of Indiana a good bank?

First Internet Bank Of Indiana earns a Bankzia Trust Grade of B (84/100, "Strong"), based on a financial-strength score of 84/100 (it has no CFPB complaints on record). Well-capitalized (7.6% capital ratio); Profitable (ROA 0.32%).

Is First Internet Bank Of Indiana FDIC-insured?

Yes. First Internet Bank Of Indiana is a FDIC-insured bank (FDIC certificate #34607). Deposits are protected up to the standard FDIC limit of $250,000 per depositor, per ownership category.

How big is First Internet Bank Of Indiana?

First Internet Bank Of Indiana holds $5.7 billion in total assets, ranking 83rd of 89 banks we track in Indiana. It operates 2 branches.

Does First Internet Bank Of Indiana have CFPB complaints?

No CFPB complaints against First Internet Bank Of Indiana appear in our data over the analysis window, which is typical for a bank of this size.

Similar Banks

First Financial Bank, National Association
bank · Terre Haute, IN · $6.1B assets
United Fidelity Bank, Fsb
bank · Evansville, IN · $6.3B assets
Horizon Bank
bank · Michigan City, IN · $6.5B assets
Lake City Bank
bank · Warsaw, IN · $7.1B assets · 5 complaints
First Farmers Bank & Trust Co.
bank · Converse, IN · $3.6B assets
Star Financial Bank
bank · Fort Wayne, IN · $3.2B assets · 1 complaints

Financial data from FDIC call reports; complaint data from the CFPB Consumer Complaint Database. Bankzia is an independent resource and is not affiliated with any government agency or financial institution. Figures are for general information, not financial advice.

From the Blog

View all guides →